What to do with your professional corporation’s surplus
A doctor, dentist, lawyer or consultant with a professional corporation (a Canadian-controlled private corporation, or CCPC) usually ends the year with money the business does not need. It can stay in the corporation and be invested there, or come out to you and go into your RRSP, your TFSA or your mortgage. There is no answer that suits everyone: it depends on the return you expect, your tax rate when you retire, and how much the corporation already earns from investments. The Surplus tab of the Holdco Payout Comparison works it out with your own numbers.
The four uses
- Retain and invest in the corporation. The surplus is taxed at the small-business rate (in British Columbia 11% on the first $500,000 of active business income, against 27% above it) and the rest is invested inside the corporation. It is the largest amount to start investing, but the corporation’s investment income is taxed at a high rate, and the money is taxed again as a dividend when it comes out to you.
- Salary, then RRSP. A salary is deducted by the corporation, so it is not taxed there. You pay personal tax on it, but an RRSP contribution of the same amount takes it back off your taxable income. A salary also creates RRSP room (18% of it, up to $33,810 for 2026) and costs CPP contributions, yours and the corporation’s. If you already take a salary that reaches the RRSP limit, a further salary creates no more room.
- Dividend, then TFSA. The corporation pays a non-eligible dividend out of its after-tax income; you pay personal tax on it, and put what is left in your TFSA. The room is small ($7,000 for 2026, plus any unused room), but the growth is never taxed again, and it takes money out of the corporation’s investment income.
- Dividend, then mortgage. The same dividend, used to prepay your mortgage. The return is certain: it is the mortgage rate, after tax, because the interest you no longer pay was never deductible.
The uses can be combined, and often are: filling the TFSA each year and keeping the rest in the corporation is a common pattern. The Surplus tab lets you split the surplus and say where the rest goes when one use is full.
Why keeping it in the corporation is not simply better
Leaving the surplus in the corporation defers personal tax, sometimes for decades. But what it earns there is taxed differently from the business income:
- Interest, foreign income and the taxable half of capital gains are taxed at about 50% in the corporation (50⅔% in British Columbia). 30⅔% of that income is refundable: the corporation gets it back when it pays taxable dividends.
- Dividends from Canadian public companies carry a refundable tax of 38⅓% (Part IV tax), also refunded when the corporation pays taxable dividends.
- The untaxed half of a capital gain goes into the capital dividend account and can be paid to you tax-free. See the capital dividend account explained.
Canada’s tax system aims to make income cost about the same whether it is earned personally or through a corporation and then paid out (this is called integration). It is not exact, and the gaps decide the answer: low returns, a high tax rate in retirement or the grind below make retaining less attractive; high, deferred growth makes it more attractive.
The passive income grind on the small-business rate
The small-business rate applies to the first $500,000 of active business income a year (the business limit). That limit shrinks when the corporation, together with corporations associated with it, earned more than $50,000 of investment income in the previous year: $5 off the limit for every $1 above $50,000, so it is gone at $150,000 (Income Tax Act s.125(5.1)(b)). The income counted is the “adjusted aggregate investment income” of s.125(7): interest, foreign income, the taxable half of capital gains, and portfolio dividends (dividends from companies it does not control).
For a professional who keeps investing in the corporation, this is often what tips the balance. At a 5% return, about $1 million to $2 million of corporate investments earns enough to start grinding the limit, depending on the mix. Once the limit is ground, active business income above it is taxed at the general rate, which makes retaining it far less attractive.
Two provinces do not grind their own limit, and the others do. Ontario sets its business limit “without reference to subsection 125 (5.1)” of the federal Act (Taxation Act, 2007 s.31(1)(b)), and New Brunswick deems the federal reduction to be zero for its own deduction (Income Tax Act s.57(2.6)). The federal limit is still ground in both, and in New Brunswick the provincial deduction needs a federal one, so it is lost once the federal limit is fully gone. The other provinces and territories reduce their limit as the federal one is reduced. Alberta applies section 125(5.1) itself (Corporate Tax Act s.22(4)); Manitoba multiplies its limit by the federal limit after the reduction over the federal limit before it (Income Tax Act s.7(2)); British Columbia, Newfoundland and Labrador, the Northwest Territories, Nunavut and Yukon use the federal limit itself; Quebec reduces its own $500,000 by the same formula and the same investment income (Taxation Act s.771.2.1.8). Saskatchewan sets its limit at 120% of the federal one (Income Tax Act, 2000 s.56.6) and Prince Edward Island reads $600,000 into the same formula (Income Tax Act s.37.11.7), so their $600,000 shrinks in proportion and is also gone at $150,000 (the tab shows a caution for Prince Edward Island: read literally, the Act could give a slightly larger limit). Quebec also needs more than 5,500 paid hours a year for its deduction (s.771.0.2.4); the tab asks one yes or no and does not split the phase-in between 5,000 and 5,500 hours. Nova Scotia sets a $700,000 limit in words that do not say whether the federal reduction still applies to it; the tab reduces the $700,000 in proportion ($7 off for each $1 over $50,000), as Prince Edward Island and Saskatchewan write it, and shows a caution. Confirm that with your accountant.
How the Surplus tab compares them
- It projects each year from your age now to your retirement age: the corporation’s tax, the grind, its pools (RDTOH, GRIP, CDA), your RRSP, TFSA and mortgage.
- At the retirement age it values everything after tax, in today’s dollars: the RRSP at your tax rate in retirement, the TFSA in full, the mortgage interest saved, and the corporation wound up (its investments sold and everything paid out as dividends, the tax-free capital dividend first, with the dividend refunds).
- It shows each use at 100% and your own split, a table at three retirement incomes, and, on request, the breakeven investment return at which keeping the money in the corporation and the best personal use come out even.
- The tax rates in retirement are per dollar at the income you enter. Around the age amount’s clawback range a lower income can show a slightly higher rate (in British Columbia the age amount is still being reduced at $60,000 and is gone by $90,000), so a lower retirement income does not always give a higher value.
What happens after the retirement age, including your estate, is for the Holding Company Retirement Planner. The Surplus tab can save its balances at that age as a file the planner imports.
Example (the Surplus tab’s own figures, with its assumptions). A BC professional, aged 45, retiring at 65, already takes a $200,000 salary. The corporation has $400,000 in cash and $200,000 in ETFs, and a $100,000 surplus each year (growing with 2% inflation). A 5% return, $20,000 of RRSP room, $7,000 of TFSA room, a $400,000 mortgage at 5% over 20 years, and a $90,000 retirement income. After tax at 65, in today’s dollars, each use at 100%: retain about $2.44 million, salary then RRSP about $2.35 million, dividend then mortgage about $2.35 million, dividend then TFSA about $2.32 million. The salary use barely reaches the RRSP: the $200,000 salary already creates more room than the RRSP limit, so most of it flows on to the next use. The breakeven return is about 3.4%: below it, the personal uses come out ahead.
Individual pension plans (IPP)
An individual pension plan is a defined benefit pension plan your corporation sets up for you as its employee. The corporation’s contributions are deductible, and they can be larger than what an RRSP allows, especially at older ages. It needs salary, an actuary’s valuations and yearly filings, and it reduces your RRSP room. It is usually looked at by owners in their 40s and older who pay themselves a salary. The Surplus tab does not model an IPP; if it might suit you, ask an adviser who sets them up.
Other things to check
- One main client. A corporation that mainly provides your services to one client may be a personal services business: no small-business rate and few deductions. The tab only warns.
- Family shareholders. Dividends to a spouse or adult child can be taxed at the top rate under the tax on split income (TOSI). See the TOSI check on the Payout tab.
- RESPs and insurance. A child’s RESP is a real use for surplus money, but a family decision more than a tax one; corporate-owned life insurance is an estate tool. Neither is modelled.
Try it with your own numbers. The Surplus tab is free, needs no sign-up and runs in your browser. It covers every province and territory.
Open the Surplus tabPlan retirement from thereGeneral information for planning and education, not financial, tax or legal advice. The rules for corporations are complex and the right choice depends on facts the tool does not know; have an accountant review your own situation.